Newsletter recommendations

A cross-promotion feature where newsletters suggest each other to new subscribers, usually right after signup, so one signup can lead to several.

By Azande PorterUpdated 3 min read

What are newsletter recommendations?

Newsletter recommendations are a cross-promotion feature where publications suggest each other to new subscribers, usually right after signup, so a reader can join several newsletters with a click or two.

They work because the moment after a signup form is submitted is the moment of highest intent. A reader who just joined a newsletter about freelance pricing is a good prospect for one about freelance contracts. Recommendations are reciprocal by habit rather than by rule: you recommend newsletters your readers would like, and those writers often return the favor.

How do recommendations work on beehiiv, Kit, Ghost, and Substack?

beehiiv

Free recommendations are available on all plans. You can feature up to four publications in your Top 4, which appears in your signup flow after someone subscribes (if enabled) and can be inserted into posts, according to beehiiv's Recommendations Network FAQ. What beehiiv used to call Boosts are now paid recommendations, where you pay another publisher for each verified subscriber they send you.

Kit

Kit's version runs through the Kit Creator Network. You can recommend up to 20 creators at a time, and Kit displays a maximum of five recommendations on your forms and landing pages. Smart Recommendations can fill slots automatically with creators whose content is similar to yours. Paid recommendations let other creators pay you for each successful referral, once they approve your application.

Ghost

Ghost's recommendations are a beta feature, set up under Settings, Growth, Recommendations. The recommendations pop-up appears whenever a new member signs up, and you can recommend sites that are not on Ghost. One-click subscribing currently works only between Ghost sites.

Substack

Substack introduced recommendations in 2022. Recommended publications appear to readers after they subscribe.

Settings and limits change often, so confirm them in your provider's help center before planning around a number.

What is the difference between free and paid recommendations?

A free recommendation is an endorsement, and no money moves. A paid recommendation is acquisition you buy or sell per subscriber. On beehiiv, paid recommendations need a paid plan and pay out only for subscribers who pass verification. On Kit, the paying creator decides who may recommend them.

Price paid recommendations like any other channel, as a cost per subscriber, and judge them on what those subscribers do after they join rather than on the signup count.

Are subscribers from recommendations good subscribers?

They can be, but they joined with less context than someone who read your posts for months. They picked your newsletter from a short description, often alongside others, so expect a wider spread in engagement.

After a few editions, compare the share of engaged subscribers from recommendations with your other sources. Make your first email do the introduction their signup skipped. Recommend only newsletters you actually read, because your endorsement is what the new subscriber is trusting.

How are recommendations different from a referral program?

A referral program asks your readers to bring people in, one personal share at a time. Recommendations borrow other newsletters' signup moments and lend them yours. The two stack well, and both should appear as separate sources when you track newsletter growth rate. Our comparison of beehiiv and Kit covers how each provider's growth tools fit a newsletter-run business.

Platform details checked

How Distinctful helps

Recommendations run inside your newsletter provider. Distinctful connects beehiiv, Kit, or Ghost and reports subscribers and editions, plus where new subscribers came from when beehiiv or Kit report it, so recommendation signups sit beside your other sources and your social posts. See newsletter analytics.

Related terms

Go deeper

Compare where your new subscribers came from

Connect beehiiv or Kit and see subscriber sources beside the posts you published.